Aha, I am honored.
Well, overall, I disagreed with the thread idea earlier because the idea of having a topic like that for all categories, I feel as if it could get pretty disorganized? not to mention that people would probably start conversations regarding certain posts, and so on and so forth.
On the other hand, I think @Hanna_Brassheart touched upon a good solution. The only thing is that if you had one big thread for all these multiple things- say I'm a pianist (ohohoho, I am) and I want to find some "YKYA_W"s about pianoes. It'd be a bit harder to find them. I'm not saying it's impossible; in fact, that's what the search bar's for. But in my mind, that's enough reason to create a newer "YKYA_W" thread if the topic itself is big enough.
For example: ALL Aetherlighters can participate in the "YKYAAW" thread.
And it's not really a secret that a pretty big chunk of people here are also writers, which is why I made my own edition.
I think this also justifies @Christopher_Puddlevest1's version too, as I'm pretty sure the majority of us are bookworms.
On the other hand, if someone wanted to make a YOU KNOW YOU'RE A GODZILLA FAN WHEN- thread, then I'd probably be against that. because although Godzilla is amazing, I'm pretty sure I'm the only Kaiju-enthusiast on the forums at this point hahaha.
This may be flawed judgement, but it's what I think. Now I need to sign off to feed my dogs haha. Hope this helped. :wink"