Oooof, I forgot about this.
Well, for starters, I don't think this could be closed under the CoC/CoNC-ACD/Bad Guys topics' precedence, because of the context. CoNC and Bad Guys were deemed spam because they were created solely for the purpose of competing with their sister topics. Now of course, competition is fine! It's just that these groups weren't set up with any purpose besides competition, while the original topics had valid purposes.
This topic doesn't have a sister topic, so it wouldn't fall under that category.
I think the key thing that makes a group is whether or not it has a legitimate role-play or Aetherlight related purpose. If there isn't a purpose to a group, they can use the meeting topic, of course! But it wouldn't warrant a whole topic, know what I'm saying?
That's just what I think makes sense in the context.
So I guess the question for Shadow would be, "What are the goals of this group?"