I literally facepalmed myself over this conversation. @Hans_Oddcraft I think you are right.
Because of God's Holy and Just nature, He has every right to kill humans simply because some humans openly defy God, BUT because of God's Loving and Gracious nature He also gives mercy to all unsaved humans to draw them closer to Himself.
I think it depends on the situation of how God's will is most glorified through justice or mercy.
I would just trust Him to make the Holy and Loving choice concerning someone's life. His nature can be confusing and conflicting, but we can trust Him to do the right thing.