I'm no good at this.
@Hans_Oddcraft, tournament-style chess set, because he deserves to have one.
@Eerie_Coppernight, about $2000 to spend on inventions and computer upgrades.
@Hanna_Brassheart, a real Morse Code Machine and a copy of Berdyaev's The Destiny of Man.
@Jessie_Dearsnap, an all-expenses-paid weekend getaway and some small dragon plushies for the children.
@Lilliana_Umbrellascope, a Fog gauntlet.
@Iliara_Mustardtop, an alpaca plushie.
@caleb_Larkmagnet1 An Aetherlight teleporting map that actually works.
@Miss_K1 10 Aether Boilers and a box of ivermectin, heh. Also bottles of lemon and honey, and some chocolate truffles.
@Levi_Orangeburst A T-shirt with "I am not a comedian" written on it.
That's all I can think of for now.